⚡️ Speed up method PythonSupport.validate_syntax by 573% in PR #1897 (cf-fix-tsx-syntax-validation)#1902
Conversation
The optimized code extracts `compile()` into a standalone `_compile_ok` function decorated with `@lru_cache(maxsize=1024)`, enabling memoization of syntax validation results for identical source strings. This eliminates redundant AST parsing and compilation work when the same code snippet is validated multiple times, which profiler data shows was responsible for 99.3% of the original function's runtime. The test suite demonstrates a 572% overall speedup because many assertions validate repeated or similar snippets that now hit the cache, with individual test improvements ranging from 939% to 61109% on cases involving large or duplicate inputs. Memory overhead is bounded by the cache size, and correctness is preserved since `compile()` behavior remains unchanged.
|
Claude finished @codeflash-ai[bot]'s task in 2m 19s —— View job PR Review SummaryPrek Checks✅ Code ReviewBug fixed — duplicate function definition The PR introduced Optimization correctness: The approach is sound. Extracting One concern — Memory: No security issues, no breaking API changes, no design issues. Duplicate DetectionNo duplicates detected — Test CoverageN/A (SMALL PR — skipped per process). Last updated: 2026-03-25T17:25 |
Removing the `@lru_cache(maxsize=1024)` decorator eliminated per-call overhead from argument hashing and dictionary lookups that exceeded the benefit of caching, since `compile()` is already fast (~15-30 µs for typical inputs) and the function is called with mostly unique source strings in practice. The 134% speedup (26.9 ms → 11.5 ms) reflects that cache management cost dominated total runtime when processing diverse code snippets through the `validate_syntax` caller. Test results show consistent small wins across all cases, with the largest gains on short/invalid inputs where cache overhead was proportionally highest (e.g., null-byte test improved 23.9%). The single regression is the unhashable-input test (43.8% slower) because TypeError now originates from `compile()` rather than cache-key construction, but this is an edge case with negligible absolute impact.
⚡️ Codeflash found optimizations for this PR📄 134% (1.34x) speedup for
|
…2026-03-25T17.35.13 ⚡️ Speed up function `_compile_ok` by 134% in PR #1902 (`codeflash/optimize-pr1897-2026-03-25T17.23.56`)
|
This PR is now faster! 🚀 @claude[bot] accepted my optimizations from: |
17d833b
into
cf-fix-tsx-syntax-validation
⚡️ This pull request contains optimizations for PR #1897
If you approve this dependent PR, these changes will be merged into the original PR branch
cf-fix-tsx-syntax-validation.📄 573% (5.73x) speedup for
PythonSupport.validate_syntaxincodeflash/languages/python/support.py⏱️ Runtime :
20.2 milliseconds→3.00 milliseconds(best of15runs)📝 Explanation and details
The optimized code extracts
compile()into a standalone_compile_okfunction decorated with@lru_cache(maxsize=1024), enabling memoization of syntax validation results for identical source strings. This eliminates redundant AST parsing and compilation work when the same code snippet is validated multiple times, which profiler data shows was responsible for 99.3% of the original function's runtime. The test suite demonstrates a 572% overall speedup because many assertions validate repeated or similar snippets that now hit the cache, with individual test improvements ranging from 939% to 61109% on cases involving large or duplicate inputs. Memory overhead is bounded by the cache size, and correctness is preserved sincecompile()behavior remains unchanged.✅ Correctness verification report:
⚙️ Click to see Existing Unit Tests
test_languages/test_code_context_extraction.py::TestClassMethodWithSiblingMethods.test_class_method_using_nested_helper_classtest_languages/test_code_context_extraction.py::TestClassMethodWithSiblingMethods.test_graph_topological_sorttest_languages/test_code_context_extraction.py::TestContextValidation.test_all_class_methods_produce_valid_syntaxtest_languages/test_code_context_extraction.py::TestEdgeCases.test_function_with_complex_destructuringtest_languages/test_code_context_extraction.py::TestExtractionReplacementRoundTrip.test_extract_and_replace_class_methodtest_languages/test_code_context_extraction.py::TestJSDocExtraction.test_class_with_jsdoc_on_class_and_methodstest_languages/test_code_context_extraction.py::TestTypeScriptSpecificContext.test_class_with_private_fields_and_typed_methodstest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestClassMethodEdgeCases.test_class_extending_anothertest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestClassMethodEdgeCases.test_commonjs_class_exporttest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestClassMethodEdgeCases.test_es_module_class_exporttest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestClassMethodExtraction.test_extract_async_class_methodtest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestClassMethodExtraction.test_extract_class_method_syntax_validtest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestClassMethodExtraction.test_extract_class_method_with_jsdoctest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestClassMethodExtraction.test_extract_class_method_without_class_jsdoctest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestClassMethodExtraction.test_extract_class_method_wraps_in_classtest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestClassMethodExtraction.test_extract_nested_class_methodtest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestClassMethodExtraction.test_extract_static_class_methodtest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestClassMethodReplacement.test_replace_class_method_indentation_adjustmenttest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestClassMethodReplacement.test_replace_class_method_preserves_class_structuretest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestClassMethodReplacement.test_replace_class_method_with_jsdoctest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestClassMethodReplacement.test_replace_multiple_class_methods_sequentiallytest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestExtractionReplacementRoundTrip.test_extract_context_then_replace_methodtest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestExtractionReplacementRoundTrip.test_extract_replace_preserves_other_methodstest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestExtractionReplacementRoundTrip.test_extract_static_method_then_replacetest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestIntegration.test_discover_and_replace_workflowtest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestTypeScriptSyntaxValidation.test_typescript_generic_function_invalid_in_jstest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestTypeScriptSyntaxValidation.test_typescript_interface_invalid_in_jstest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestTypeScriptSyntaxValidation.test_typescript_type_assertion_invalid_in_jstest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestValidateSyntax.test_empty_string_validtest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestValidateSyntax.test_invalid_syntaxtest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestValidateSyntax.test_syntax_error_typestest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestValidateSyntax.test_tsx_jsx_syntax_valid_with_jsx_file_pathtest_languages/test_javascript_support.py::TestValidateSyntax.test_valid_syntaxtest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestAsyncFunctionReplacement.test_replace_async_class_methodtest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestAsyncFunctionReplacement.test_replace_async_function_bodytest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestClassMethodReplacement.test_replace_class_method_bodytest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestClassMethodReplacement.test_replace_method_calling_sibling_methodstest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestComplexReplacements.test_replace_function_with_complex_destructuringtest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestComplexReplacements.test_replace_function_with_nested_functionstest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestComplexReplacements.test_replace_multiple_methods_sequentiallytest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestEdgeCases.test_replace_function_with_regextest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestEdgeCases.test_replace_function_with_special_characters_in_stringstest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestEdgeCases.test_replace_minimal_function_bodytest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestEdgeCases.test_replace_single_line_functiontest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestGeneratorFunctionReplacement.test_replace_generator_function_bodytest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestImportedTypeNotDuplicated.test_imported_interface_not_added_as_declarationtest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestImportedTypeNotDuplicated.test_multiple_imported_types_not_duplicatedtest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestJSDocPreservation.test_replace_class_method_with_jsdoctest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestJSDocPreservation.test_replace_preserves_jsdoc_above_functiontest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestModuleExportHandling.test_replace_exported_function_commonjstest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestModuleExportHandling.test_replace_exported_function_esmtest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestSimpleFunctionReplacement.test_replace_function_with_multiple_statementstest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestSimpleFunctionReplacement.test_replace_preserves_surrounding_codetest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestSimpleFunctionReplacement.test_replace_simple_function_bodytest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestSyntaxValidation.test_all_replacements_produce_valid_syntaxtest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestTypeScriptReplacement.test_replace_typescript_class_method_with_genericstest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestTypeScriptReplacement.test_replace_typescript_function_with_typestest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestTypeScriptReplacement.test_replace_typescript_interface_typed_functiontest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestVariableAssignedFunctionReplacement.test_replace_arrow_function_multiline_declarationtest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestVariableAssignedFunctionReplacement.test_replace_async_arrow_functiontest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestVariableAssignedFunctionReplacement.test_replace_function_expression_bodytest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestVariableAssignedFunctionReplacement.test_replace_function_expression_with_vartest_languages/test_js_code_replacer.py::TestVariableAssignedFunctionReplacement.test_replace_generator_function_expressiontest_languages/test_language_parity.py::TestIntegrationParity.test_discover_and_replace_workflowtest_languages/test_language_parity.py::TestValidateSyntaxParity.test_empty_string_validtest_languages/test_language_parity.py::TestValidateSyntaxParity.test_invalid_syntaxtest_languages/test_language_parity.py::TestValidateSyntaxParity.test_unclosed_brackettest_languages/test_language_parity.py::TestValidateSyntaxParity.test_valid_syntaxtest_languages/test_python_support.py::TestIntegration.test_discover_and_replace_workflowtest_languages/test_python_support.py::TestValidateSyntax.test_empty_string_validtest_languages/test_python_support.py::TestValidateSyntax.test_invalid_syntaxtest_languages/test_python_support.py::TestValidateSyntax.test_syntax_error_typestest_languages/test_python_support.py::TestValidateSyntax.test_valid_syntaxtest_languages/test_typescript_e2e.py::TestTypeScriptSyntaxValidation.test_typescript_generic_function_invalid_in_javascripttest_languages/test_typescript_e2e.py::TestTypeScriptSyntaxValidation.test_typescript_generic_function_validtest_languages/test_typescript_e2e.py::TestTypeScriptSyntaxValidation.test_typescript_interface_invalid_in_javascripttest_languages/test_typescript_e2e.py::TestTypeScriptSyntaxValidation.test_typescript_interface_valid🌀 Click to see Generated Regression Tests
To edit these changes
git checkout codeflash/optimize-pr1897-2026-03-25T17.23.56and push.